The book Through a Glass Darkly: A Comparison of Self-Proclaimed “Mahdist” States throughout History to the Theory of the (True) Mahdist State Yet to Come by Dr. Timothy R. Furnish is a scholarly exploration of Mahdism—messianic beliefs in Islam centered on the awaited figure of the Mahdi.
Core Focus:
Furnish compares various historical movements and regimes that claimed Mahdist legitimacy, analyzing how they stack up against the theological concept of the true Mahdi expected in Islamic eschatology. The title, borrowed from 1 Corinthians 13:12 (“For now we see through a glass, darkly…”), suggests that these historical Mahdist states were imperfect reflections or misinterpretations of the genuine, divinely guided Mahdist era yet to come.
Key Themes:
- Typology vs. Reality: Furnish treats these past Mahdist claims not as fulfillments, but as types or shadows of the eschatological Mahdi, each revealing partial truths and significant distortions.
- Comparative History: The book analyzes Mahdist movements such as:
- Ibn Tumart and the Almohads (12th century North Africa)
- The Mahdi of Sudan (Muhammad Ahmad, late 19th century)
- Juhayman al-‘Utaybi and the 1979 Mecca Uprising
- The Fatimid Caliphate (Shiʿi Ismaili Mahdist rule)
- Sociopolitical Impacts: These movements often involved revolutionary change, legal reform, and violent upheaval under the banner of purifying Islam and establishing divine justice.
Significance in the Field:
- Interdisciplinary Approach: Blends Islamic theology, political history, and comparative religion.
- Christian Perspective: Though written by a Christian scholar, the work avoids polemic and engages with Islamic sources and beliefs with academic respect.
- Modern Relevance: Helps understand the continuing allure of Mahdism in parts of the Muslim world and its potential for shaping radical or revolutionary movements.
Download
