In the issue of Imamate, between reason and narration, which is given precedence?

18 March 24 Question and Answer
As can be understood from the question itself, issues are of two types. One type are the issues that are ascertained through reason and are accepted through application of logical procedures and intellectual proofs, such as proving the existence of Allah, His essential attributes of perfection, and the necessity of prophecy, i.e. the proof of prophecy in general. The other type are those issues that are proved solely through narration, …
READ MORE

The Number of the Shi‘a Imams

18 March 24 Question and Answer
We have given sufficient explanation about the tradition or traditions that indicate that the number of Imams (peace be upon them) is thirteen in the treatise “Clarity of Vision for One Who Follows the Twelve Imams.” There, we have clarified that the a tradition with this meaning does not exist; moreover, even if such a tradition were to exist, it is a tradition with a single narrator and with regard …
READ MORE

The Number of the Shi‘a Imams

18 March 24
We have given sufficient explanation about the tradition or traditions that indicate that the number of Imams (peace be upon them) is thirteen in the treatise “Clarity of Vision for One Who Follows the Twelve Imams.” There, we have clarified that the a tradition with this meaning does not exist; moreover, even if such a tradition were to exist, it is a tradition with a single narrator and with regard …
READ MORE

Please explain the relationship of these two parts (religious and political issues) with the principle of Imamate and explain to what extent Shi‘a have accepted this issue.

18 March 24 Question and Answer
As has been indicated, their range of leadership includes both parts, and in reality these two parts are inseparable. However, the issue that was the focus of attention and covetousness of usurping politicians and oppressors was political leadership and taking control of the leadership of society. Thus, their opposition to the Imams (peace be upon them) was focused on this aspect, and if they opposed them from the aspect of …
READ MORE

Why were the conduct, manner, and methods of the Imams (peace be upon them) not the same in regard to performance of their duty?

18 March 24 Question and Answer
Contrary to what is said, the conduct of the Imams (peace be upon them) in confronting various events that were similar to an extent was not very divergent, since all of their conduct was within the scope of the principles and agenda of Shiaism, which are the original principles of Islam itself. All of their actions and programs demonstrated the truth of Islam and its redemptive teachings. And if we …
READ MORE

explain the difference between Allah’s and the Imam’s knowledge and between the Imam’s and the Prophet’s knowledge.

18 March 24 Question and Answer
ANSWER: Anyone who studies the books of history, traditions, and biographies will not doubt the fact that the Holy Prophet (peace be upon him and his family) and the pure Imams (peace be upon them) made known many unseen matters, most of which took place in the world within a short period. These reports, especially what has come down from the person of the noble Prophet (peace be upon him …
READ MORE

What was the secret of appointing the Imams to the position of Imamate and Wilayah? Is human intellect able to understand this?

18 March 24 Question and Answer
This question is not exclusive to the appointment of the Imams (peace be upon them), but can be brought up regarding the selection of all the prophets and even angels such as Jibra’il, the Trustee of revelation, and regarding the superiority of some prophets over others and some nations and individuals over others, and in the same way about the superiority of humanity over many other types of creation. The …
READ MORE